Huge pickle fan over here. Just know that I am the kinda gal who will always ask you if you want your spear at a diner!!! Iām devastated that Brooklyn doesnāt have more options for Polish pickle soup. Karczma in Greenpoint is one of the rare spots that does it but there are some recipes online if you donāt live near there and want to give it a go on your own. As the temperature drops, I canāt recommend it enough ā itās the perfect balance of tart and creamy. Sometimes I dream of owning my own lunch counter with pickle soup and pickle backs on deck.